- Sample
- Training instructors in simulators (fire house, container, gas simulator); 19 people according to the Sousa 2022 review.
- Method
- Dermal collectors under clothing (chest, back), hands; urine (1-hydroxypyrene, 1-naphthol), air.
- Result
- Whole-body dermal PAH exposure ~1200 ng/cm² (fire house), ~760 ng/cm² (container), ~30 ng/cm² (gas). Undergloves reduced PAHs on hands by about 80 % (8.7 vs 48.4 ng/cm²). There was no difference between two types of turnout gear.
- Limitations
- Instructors in a training environment only; small sample; verified from the abstract, method details in the full text.
Studies on firefighters' skin
An overview of studies that directly measured contamination of firefighters' skin after fires or training, or tested how effective decon is. For each: sample, method, main result and limitations.
What is proven and what is expert judgement
| Claim | Support |
|---|---|
| Occupational exposure as a firefighter is a Group 1 carcinogen | Study IARC 2022 |
| Skin contamination correlates with urinary PAH metabolites | Study Wingfors 2018, Keir 2017 |
| Water with detergent reduces PAHs on skin, wipes not significantly | Study Keir 2023 |
| Wipes reduce PAHs on skin, less than washing | Study Fent 2017, Keir 2023 |
| A shower after a fire reduces PAHs on skin | Study Saber 2025 |
| Water alone does not remove greasy contamination | Model Šromová 2026 |
| Early decon reduces the long-term load on the skin | Expert judgement not measured directly |
| Time limits of 1 hour and 10 minutes | Practical recommendation |
| Multiples of the technician's dose when washing PPE | Model estimate |
Studies that measured firefighters' skin
Units: studies report PAHs on skin in ng/cm², µg/m² or ng per swab. 1 µg/m² = 0.1 ng/cm². Values in ng per swab are not directly comparable between studies.
- Sample
- Instructors in conventional and modern simulators.
- Method
- Urine biomonitoring, air measurements, dermal exposure.
- Result
- The authors conclude that dermal exposure contributed to PAH uptake and apparently delayed the excretion of 1-hydroxypyrene and 1-naphthol. They propose biological limits of 1-OHP for simulators.
- Limitations
- Skin measurements are not quantified in the abstract; verified from the abstract only.
- Sample
- 18 firefighter instructors from Chicago, 30 participations in 2 rounds of 3 controlled fires (non-smokers, men).
- Method
- Corn-oil swabs: forearm, neck, scrotum (pre/post), hands and face (post). Breath (benzene), urine, personal air.
- Result
- Neck: median 40.4 → 52.0 µg/m² (round 1, p = 0.02), 53.8 → 62.8 µg/m² (round 2, n.s.). No significant change on the scrotum. The authors infer that PAHs entered the body mainly through the skin, especially the neck.
- Limitations
- Small sample; the oil matrix interfered with the analysis (only 6 PAHs); some pumps failed; urinary ELISA is non-specific.
- Sample
- Firefighters from two stations; 8 overhaul activities, 3 station samples; number of people swabbed not reported.
- Method
- Face and neck swabs at the fire scene; air (PM, PAHs).
- Result
- Face and neck swabs contained more types of PAHs than the air, including carcinogenic benzofluoranthene. Individual concentrations were low.
- Limitations
- Results in µg/swab (not comparable with ng/cm²); small number of events; swab method not described in the abstract.
- Sample
- 28 firefighters from 4 departments, training in burn houses (wood fuel).
- Method
- Swabs from several sites (back, neck, wrist, forehead, fingers according to the Sousa 2022 review); urine (methoxyphenols, OH-PAHs); air.
- Result
- Swabs showed exposure to smoke over the whole body. According to the Sousa 2022 review, ΣPAH was highest on the back (4.58 ng/cm²) and the most carcinogenic PAHs on the forehead (2.16 ng/cm²). Urinary metabolites rose significantly within 24 h.
- Limitations
- Only one fuel type (wood); large variability between roles; swab figures verified via the review, not from the full text.
- Sample
- 41 firefighters (37 men, 4 women), 12 controlled bedroom fires in a single-family house.
- Method
- Hand and neck swabs (corn-oil cloth) before and after; neck again after cleaning with commercial wipes. Turnout gear swabs before and after gross decon.
- Result
- Hands: median 135 µg/m² (attack) and 226 µg/m² (search). PAHs on 76 % of hand swabs and 41 % of neck swabs. Wipes reduced PAHs on the neck by a median of 54 % (n = 22, p = 0.004). Wet decon of gear with soap ~−85 %, dry brush ~−23 %, air ~0 %.
- Limitations
- Small sample; unknown swab collection efficiency (the authors estimate ≥25 % was not captured); excluding non-detectable samples may have overestimated decon effectiveness.
- Sample
- Ottawa Fire Services firefighters before and after real fires (28 according to the Sousa 2022 review), control group of office workers.
- Method
- Skin swabs (neck, wrist, forehead), personal air, urine (OH-PAHs, mutagenicity).
- Result
- ΣPAH on skin rose ~3.3× (0.5 → 1.6 ng/cm², according to Sousa 2022). After fires, urinary PAH metabolites and mutagenicity rose significantly. The authors consider skin contamination at real fires to be the main exposure route.
- Limitations
- Small sample; heterogeneous real fires; swab figures verified via the review, full text not available.
- Sample
- Skin: 4 firefighters (1 instructor, 3 trainees) during ~60 min training. Also swabs at 2 stations and from vehicles.
- Method
- Swabs of the back and front of the neck, jawline and hands before and ~10 min after training; 16 PAHs (EPA) + 3 others.
- Result
- Most PAHs rose significantly at all sites after training, most on the hands. Benzo[a]pyrene was found on the hands and throat of almost everyone. The modelled risk ratio was highest for the hands.
- Limitations
- Only 4 people and one training session; unknown PPE use history; cancer risk is a model with assumptions (20% absorption); no biomonitoring.
- Sample
- 20 firefighting students (aged 19–29, non-smokers); gear protection factor tested on 1 instructor.
- Method
- Neck swab with an acetone filter (30 cm²) before and after; air outside/inside the gear; urine (1-OHP etc.).
- Result
- ΣPAH on the neck median 21 → 99 ng/swab (~5×, p = 0.01); B[a]P measurable after the exercise in 18/20. Urinary 1-OHP ~7.6× within 6 h. 1-OHP correlated best with skin deposition; gear reduced PAHs from outside to inside by an average factor of 146.
- Limitations
- Neck only; small sample; inhalation not measured directly; protection factor only 1 person, 1 garment, 1 fuel.
- Sample
- 53 young healthy participants of a firefighting course (3 days of live-fire training).
- Method
- Neck swabs, urine (1-OHP), blood (DNA damage in PBMC); control = average of 2 measurements 2 weeks before and after the course.
- Result
- Pyrene on skin +68 %, ΣPAH on skin +80 % after the exercise. Both 1-OHP and DNA damage in blood cells increased.
- Limitations
- Training, not a real incident; young recruits; inflammatory markers with no consistent response.
- Sample
- 22 career firefighters before and after a 24 h shift.
- Method
- Skin swabs, urinary 1-OHP, particles, lung function, blood.
- Result
- PAHs on skin were similar before and after the shift, regardless of participation in firefighting. Particle exposure occurred mainly after PPE was removed.
- Limitations
- Few and small fires during the study; full author list and issue number not verified (verified from the abstract).
- Sample
- 7 crew commanders during training, 9 police investigators at fire scenes (+ 8 commanders at real fires, air only).
- Method
- Tape stripping of skin on the wrist and collarbone; active and passive air sampling.
- Result
- Both gaseous and particulate PAHs on the skin. The wrists were less well protected than the collarbone area. Dermal doses comparable to US firefighters, lower than in Swedish chimney sweeps.
- Limitations
- Very small sample; skin measured only during training, not at real fires.
- Sample
- Firefighters at a controlled interior fire (11 according to Sousa 2022).
- Method
- Neck and calf swabs before and after; PAH CALUX bioassay (AhR activity) + chemical analysis; urine.
- Result
- After the fire, higher AhR activity on both neck and calf. Wiping the face and neck with a baby wipe in rehab reduced the response from the neck swab. The rise in urine was more likely caused by substances other than the measured OH-PAHs.
- Limitations
- Small sample, one scenario; the bioassay doesn't identify specific substances.
- Sample
- Same dataset as Fent 2017 (IFSI controlled fires).
- Method
- Neck and hand swabs after doffing PPE; urine, breath.
- Result
- Hands: from non-detectable values to 135 µg/m² (attack) and 226 µg/m² (search). Attack and search positions had the most PAHs on the hands; interior vs exterior attack showed no significant difference.
- Limitations
- Skin data overlap with Fent 2017, don't cite as an independent result; skin washed within ~45 min.
- Sample
- 26 firefighters (12 diesel pan fire, 14 chipboard), 15 min in the container.
- Method
- Isopropanol wipes, 20 cm² template, wrist and neck (left before, right after).
- Result
- After the chipboard fire, fluorene, phenanthrene and pyrene on the wrist rose 7–10×, phenanthrene and pyrene on the neck 12–15×. Smaller increase for diesel. Urinary metabolites stayed relatively low (quick doffing and a shower within 10 min).
- Limitations
- Simulation; small sample; no skin–urine correlation.
- Sample
- 86 non-smoking wildland firefighters (66 men, 20 women), 11 crews, Alberta and British Columbia.
- Method
- Isopropanol swabs of palms, jaw/throat, nape and chest before and after a day at the fire; urinary 1-OHP. Randomisation: shower with soap, hair washing and change of clothes vs usual practice.
- Result
- 1-OHP rose during the shift. Naphthalene dominated on the skin (on the hands in 40/84). Better hygiene reduced overnight 1-OHP only in those with naphthalene on their hands (p = 0.07).
- Limitations
- Quiet season, small numbers, many values below the detection limit; borderline statistics.
- Sample
- 88 firefighters (82 men, 6 women) from Ottawa Fire Services and the Canadian Armed Forces, 21 training fires (chipboard), 2018–2019.
- Method
- Random assignment: 2 commercial wipes, detergent with water, or no decon. Skin swabs before, after the fire and after decon; urine (OH-PAHs, mutagenicity).
- Result
- Skin: ΣPAH 1.3×, higher-molecular-weight PAHs 2.2× after the fire. Only detergent with water significantly reduced PAHs on the skin (0.72 → 0.38 ng/cm² according to the SOT 2022 abstract). Urinary metabolites rose 1.7–2.2×, no decon method affected the rise.
- Limitations
- Only one fuel; small subgroups (14 with measurable values for detergent); the soap effect can't be separated from substance type or habit; wipes not named.
- Sample
- 17 conscripts in firefighter training (12 men, 5 women); 11–14 analysed.
- Method
- Nape swab with 70% isopropanol (~3 × 6 cm), CALUX bioassay + GC-MS/MS; morning urine.
- Result
- After wood fires, skin rose by more than 400 % in the bioassay and by ~80 % chemically. After gas and without fire, small changes; minimal exposure from contaminated equipment alone.
- Limitations
- Small sample; different seasons; weak correlation between bioassay and chemistry.
- Sample
- 22 people (13 instructors, 4 fire setters, 4 supervisors, 1 logistician); swabs from 21.
- Method
- Acetone swabs of face/neck and hands/wrists at the end of training before decon (INRS M-448 method); urine 3×; air.
- Result
- Face/neck 1–67 ng/cm², hands/wrists 1–129 ng/cm². Median on hands by underglove: nitrile 4.5; latex 9.6; none 12.4; vinyl 44 ng/cm².
- Limitations
- Small sample; only 3 days; undergloves were not randomly assigned; other PAH sources can't be ruled out.
- Sample
- 25 firefighters from 5 departments (12 career, 13 volunteer).
- Method
- Tape stripping of wrist and neck (skin microRNA), isopropanol swabs of skin and gear for PAHs (GC/MS), blood; within 24 h after the fire.
- Result
- After the fire, 5 microRNAs changed significantly. Most PAH–microRNA associations involved PAHs from gear; naphthalene was the most connected. Shows a biological response, not just surface contamination.
- Limitations
- Small sample; cross-sectional design, causation can't be inferred; skin and inhalation can't be separated.
- Sample
- 26 career firefighters from 3 stations, each their own control (baseline vs intervention).
- Method
- Neck swabs with 70% isopropanol (18 cm²) before/after the shift and before/after the shower; urinary OH-PAHs. Interventions: 15 min sauna after the shower, new gear with a better barrier, shower after every call.
- Result
- A shower after a fire call reduced ΣPAH on the neck by 64 %. The sauna reduced some urinary metabolites by 28–37 %, with no significant effect on the skin. New gear gave inconsistent results.
- Limitations
- Few shifts with fires; stations not measured at the same time; self-sampling; neck only; sauna always with a shower.
Laboratory study and review
- Method
- Diffusion cells with pig skin, phenanthrene in artificial sweat; wipe solution applied after 15 min.
- Result
- Wipe solutions reduced phenanthrene penetration through the skin by 70–86 % compared with no decon. They did not increase penetration. The authors attribute the effect mainly to dilution with water.
- Limitations
- No clean-water control; only one PAH; no mechanical wiping; in vitro.
- Content
- Summary of PAH levels on firefighters' skin from studies up to 2022 and data on dermal absorption. A good source for comparing values in ng/cm².
Often cited, but did not measure skin
These papers are often mentioned in connection with skin but have no skin data of their own. Useful as context.
| Study | What it actually measured | DOI |
|---|---|---|
| Kirk & Logan 2015, J Occup Environ Hyg 12(4):227–234 | PAHs in the air outside and inside instructors' gear (430–2700 vs 32–355 µg/m³) and deposition on gear (69–290 ng/cm²). | 10.1080/15459624.2014.955184 |
| Fent et al. 2019, Int J Hyg Environ Health 222:991–1000 | Urine and breath of instructors and firefighters during training. Wipes were used, but skin was not measured. | 10.1016/j.ijheh.2019.06.006 |
| Cherry et al. 2019, Ann Work Expo Health 63(4):448–458 (Fort McMurray) | Urinary 1-OHP and a questionnaire-based skin hygiene index. Better hygiene was associated with lower 1-OHP; no swabs were taken. | 10.1093/annweh/wxz006 |
| Burgess et al. 2020, J Occup Environ Med 62(4):279–288 | Interventions (gear rinse, clean cab, shower, sauna) assessed only by urine: −36 to −40 % in firefighters and engineers. | 10.1097/JOM.0000000000001815 |
| Papas et al. 2024, Toxics 12(9):677 | Silicone wristbands worn outside the coat (passive sampler), not skin. | 10.3390/toxics12090677 |
| Everaert et al. 2023, Toxics 11(6):534 | Opinion of the Belgian Superior Health Council on nitrile undergloves. No measurements of its own. | 10.3390/toxics11060534 |
Other sources cited on this site
- Demers, P. A. et al. (2022). Carcinogenicity of occupational exposure as a firefighter. The Lancet Oncology, 23(8), 985–986. doi:10.1016/S1470-2045(22)00390-4
- Jalilian, H. et al. (2019). Cancer incidence and mortality among firefighters. International Journal of Cancer, 145(10), 2639–2646.
- Daniels, R. D. et al. (2014). Mortality and cancer incidence in a pooled cohort of US firefighters from San Francisco, Chicago and Philadelphia (1950–2009). Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 71(6), 388–397.
- Keir, J. L. A. et al. (2020). PAH and metal contamination of air and surfaces exposed to combustion emissions during emergency fire suppression. Science of the Total Environment, 698, 134211. doi:10.1016/j.scitotenv.2019.134211
- Šromová, E. (2026). Master's thesis, Tomas Bata University in Zlín. [Thesis title to be added]
How the review was verified
Each citation was checked against the publisher's page, a university repository, CDC Stacks or the reference list of another peer-reviewed study. Where the full text was not available, figures are taken from the abstract or from the Sousa et al. 2022 review, and this is noted for the study. The selection focuses on PAHs. Studies measuring only PFAS or flame retardants on skin are not included. Status as of November 2026.